Skip to content

Experts Weigh in on ETF Strategies for 401k Plans

man and woman sitting on bench in front of beach

Are you looking for ways to maximize your retirement savings? Do you want to make sure that your money is being invested wisely? If so, then you should consider exploring the benefits of ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) as part of your retirement saving plan. In this blog post, we will discuss how ETFs can help you reach your financial goals.

What is an ETF?

An ETF, or exchange-traded fund, is an investment that allows you to purchase a basket of stocks, bonds, or other securities in a single transaction. ETFs are very popular and are becoming increasingly popular due to their low-cost structure and diverse range of investments. E

TFs are traded on the stock exchange, just like stocks, and can be bought and sold throughout the day. ETFs, offer investors a way to diversify their portfolios with a broad range of assets, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, and even international investments.

Unlike mutual funds, which are priced once at the end of the day, ETFs are priced throughout the trading day. This gives investors more control over their investments and the ability to buy and sell more quickly.

How Do ETFs Work?

ETFs are investment vehicles listed on a stock exchange and traded like stocks. They offer a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, commodities, and other investments in a single security.

ETFs track an index or a basket of assets and can be bought and sold throughout the day like stocks. ETFs have become increasingly popular in recent years due to their low fees, tax efficiency, and ability to track a wide range of investments.

Furthermore, ETFs can expose international markets and sectors that are not easily accessible through other investment vehicles.

Benefits of Investing in ETFs for Retirement Savings

Hafeez Esmail from Main Management explains how ETF-managed solutions can help one’s retirement savings strategies. “Most retirement savings plans offer plan participants a variety of mutual fund choices. These participants currently pick their mutual fund allocations, which many leave unchanged for years.

The vast majority of participants that pick their portfolios have little or no financial expertise. However, they are making the asset allocation decisions that affect 90% of the variability in their portfolio returns themselves.”

Investing in ETFs for retirement savings can be a great way to build your nest egg for the future. ETFs, offer several advantages over traditional retirement savings plans, including low costs, flexibility, and diversification.

ETFs are also easy to buy and sell, so they can be an attractive option for those looking to invest in the stock market without taking on too much risk. Additionally, ETFs can provide access to markets and asset classes that may otherwise be difficult or expensive.

With all these benefits, it’s no wonder that many individuals choose to invest in ETFs when planning for retirement.

ETF Strategies Outperform Traditional Mutual Funds

The numbers bear it out. According to Main Management’s research, traditional plan participants underperform broad-based ETF strategies using indexes often by hundreds of basis points per year. Compounded over decades, the difference can be tens if not hundreds of thousands of dollars in lost retirement savings.

Plans offering ETFs provide some respite. ETFs generally are low-cost, static portfolios of stocks that mirror benchmark indexes such as the S&P 500. By contrast, mutual funds hire a manager to pick individual stocks and typically charge a higher expense ratio for this service.

“Ironically, only about 30% of large-cap managers that benchmark themselves to the S&P 500 beat this index on a five-year basis,” explains Esmail. “When buying a mutual fund, one typically pays more for lesser performance than purchasing a broad market ETF with a lower expense ratio and usually less risk.

As a result, plans rich in ETFs tend to offer better outcomes for participants than mutual fund plans because of the lower fees and broad diversification offered by ETFs.”

Plans with significant ETF offerings are only part of the solution. Main Management advises that offering an ETF-managed solution is critical. It eliminates the difficult burden of a plan participant making important asset allocation decisions over the life of the retirement plan.

Outsourcing the asset allocation decisions to institutional ETF money manager plan participants greatly improves their chances of superior performance. In addition, participants may get a better outcome without taking on substantial risks.

Disadvantages of ETFs

The only disadvantage to ETFs is that not all ETFs are created equal. “Just like mutual funds which have bad funds, ETFs also have bad funds like Exchange-traded Notes,” clarifies Abrahamson.

Abrahamson and Esmail agree that understanding the structure of an ETF is important to appreciate how it might operate versus its stated goal. “This underscores the need for an ETF money manager with an extensive understanding of the different ETF options,” explains Esmail. “As with mutual funds, ETF decisions in the hand of inexperienced investors might also be a recipe for disaster.”

Risks Associated With ETF Investing

Investing in ETFs does come with risks. The most common risk associated with ETFs is market risk, which is associated with investments in stocks, bonds, commodities, and other securities.

Market risk is affected by many factors, including economic conditions, company performance, and political events. Investors should also be aware of the potential liquidity risks associated with ETFs, as some may not be as liquid as other investments. Additionally, investors should be mindful of the fees and costs associated with ETFs, as they can add up over time.

Finally, investors should consider the potential tax implications when investing in ETFs. By understanding these risks and taking steps to manage them, investors can maximize their success when investing in ETFs for retirement savings.

Developing a Diversified Portfolio of ETFs

Creating a diversified portfolio of ETFs can help to reduce risk and maximize returns. This is done by investing in various asset classes, sectors, and styles, including stocks, bonds, commodities, and international markets.

ETFs, offer investors the ability to gain exposure to these different asset classes without purchasing individual stocks or bonds. Investing in a diversified portfolio of ETFs can reduce their risk of loss and increase the potential for higher returns over the long term.

Rebalancing Your Portfolio of ETFs

Rebalancing your portfolio of ETFs is an important part of the retirement saving process. Regularly rebalancing your portfolio will ensure that you are taking advantage of market shifts and have the right amount of exposure to different asset classes.

Also, rebalancing your portfolio allows you to adjust to changing market conditions while helping you maintain a diversified portfolio. ETF strategies for retirement saving plans should include regular rebalancing of your investments to maximize your returns and minimize risk.

Investing in International ETFs

Investing in international ETFs is another way to diversify your retirement savings portfolio. ETFs focused on international equities, bonds, commodities, and other asset classes can add an extra layer of diversification and potentially provide greater returns.

Investing in international ETFs can help protect against potential losses due to currency fluctuations. When investing in international ETFs, it is important to consider the taxes and regulatory requirements associated with the country you are investing in.

Understand the risk factors associated with that market before investing. Lastly, consider using a financial advisor to help you make the best decisions for your retirement savings plan.

Tax Considerations When Investing in ETFs

It is important to consider tax implications when investing in ETFs. ETFs are subject to both capital gains and dividend taxes, so it is essential to understand the tax implications of any ETF before investing.

Additionally, retirement accounts such as 403(b) and 457(b) plans are generally tax-deferred, so it is important to understand the tax advantages of investing in these retirement accounts.

ETF also offers annual statements of benefits which can provide a more detailed look into your retirement portfolio. The majority of ETF households have retirement accumulations, so it is important to consult with a financial advisor or mutual fund company to ensure that you are making the best decisions for your retirement savings.


Given this information, retirement plan administrators would benefit from looking closely at ETF-managed solutions because they offer far better prospects for plan participants than the status quo.